
ST. LOUIS – I spent some time chatting with Toronto GM JP Ricciardi a couple of years ago on a visit to Canada.
Make no qualms about it, JP hates the Yankees.
And, he should.
They represent everything the Blue Jays will never be from this point forward. From a financial standpoint, Toronto can’t compete with the Bombers anymore, and that, more than likely signals more time passing up north without a title.
The game has changed so much since the Jays were a dynasty in the early 90s.
Realistically, Toronto headlines a host of teams that
can't win no matter how close they got, because, larger market teams like the Yanks and Red Sox have more dollars to invest in talent.
With that said, would a desperate Ricciardi consider dealing his ace, Roy Halladay – arguably the best pitcher in the American League – to his nemesis?
I say, YES!
Especially if given the opportunity to fleece New York of some of its best prospects and young talent, understanding that Halladay is likely gone in a year-and-a-half when his contract is up.
“Doc” loves Toronto, but he’s got no shot of winning there – and he, like JP, knows that.
Halladay is 32, but he's in his prime, and still dominant. Conversely, would the Yankees consider moving some of their best prospects for a pitcher in his early 30s, maybe the center fielder of their future, Austin Jackson, in a package for Halladay. Or better yet, a deal that could include Joba Chamberlain and Phil Hughes, who were at one point, two of the most coveted pitching prospects in the game.
The stock for both has dropped a bit. Chamberlain hasn’t starred in the rotation the way he did in the bullpen, and Hughes is now in the pen, performing well in a role reversal for the two. Hughes showed some flashes of brilliance as a starter, but was moved to the bullpen when Chien-Ming Wang returned from the DL.
Sources say the Jays want Yankee second baseman Robinson Cano and Chamberlain for Halladay – a move I would welcome if the Yankees can find an adequate replacement at second for Cano. No easy task when you consider how well Cano has rebounded. It's not like I want to get rid of Cano Yankee fans, its just that you can't get something without giving up something, and Cano could be expendable for Halladay in my book.
That deal is more than likely just rumblings though, because I can’t see why the Jays would want Cano when they have Aaron Hill at second base. Unless, they want to move Hill to another position in the infield and play Cano at second.
Halladay may not even be a good fit in New York. He seems to have a small market mentality – both in personality and demeanor, likely a residual of playing in Toronto for the last several years.
Still, there’s no denying how good Halladay – on paper – could be when paired with CC Sabathia at the top of the rotation. Add AJ Burnett in the third spot and Andy Pettitte and Wang, or Hughes at the back end, and you have the best starting five in the American League, and maybe, all of baseball.
New York has one of the better rotation’s already. Halladay could cement that rotation.
I say it all the time, you can never have enough pitching. Halladay could be the difference come playoff time, especially if he makes a smooth transition to playing in the Big Apple.
A big IF, but one worth considering. The last time the Yankees acquired an ace from Toronto, it worked out pretty well. Roger Clemens won two championships and played in two more series in the Bronx (2001 and 2003) during in his time in pinstripes.
Halladay got the nod today to start the 80th annual All-Star game Tuesday night in St. Louis.
The hard-throwing right-hander is 10-3 with a 2.85 ERA this season. He spoke about the possibility of being dealt Monday in St. Louis during an early All-Star press conference.
“Yeah, it's tough," said Halladay. "Obviously I'm somewhere that I enjoy being and spent my entire career, so there's a lot I think that goes into it. But you know, I think as a player, there's that will to win and there's that will to do it in October, and basically that's all this has been about is I would like to chance. And I'm not saying it won't be Toronto. It's just what's going to be best for the organization, are we going to be able to do that, and how do we move forward.
"But it has been tough because I do enjoy Toronto so much, and you would like to be, you know, three games up in first place and not have to deal with this."
JP said he would entertain offers. Halladay sounds lukewarm on the idea of picking up and moving, but if he's motivated, there's no telling how good he could be in the heat of a pennant race.
Rumors have Halladay likely packing his bags for the National League. Reigning champs, Philadelphia, could provide Toronto with a nice package of young prospects for Halladay.
But, I think none would be better than what the Yanks could offer in Chamberlain and Hughes, or a deal that would include Cano.
You may differ on opinion on this one, but I’ll tell you, pitchers like Halladay don’t come along very often.
It’s time for the Yanks to make a move. Halladay would be a good start.